Library Losses

Local public libraries reduce services, limit events while trying to meet people’s needs

In April, the Beauchamp Branch Library, at 2111 S. Salina St., will host a series of “First Movement of the Heart: Poetry and Interpretive Dance Classes for Teens.” Jackie Warren-Moore, a local poet, and Cheryl Williams Mitchell, a dance instructor, will teach five afternoon sessions in which adolescents between the ages of 13 and 18 will learn to write poetry and then interpret their poetry as movement.

The workshops will culminate with a performance at the library April 23. Poets and Writers Inc., a national nonprofit literary organization, funds the workshops.

This program is possible due to a grant from the organization, but special events are becoming more difficult to plan, said Paschal Ugoji, a Beauchamp librarian.

Sixth-grader Williasia Williams and fifth-grader Shani Lewis of the South Side Charter Academy spend a Friday morning reading at Beauchamp Branch Library.

“The constraint we have is funding,” Ugoji said. The library often receives offers for events, he said, but they do not happen because the library cannot afford them.


Public libraries suffer from federal, state and local underfunding. In February, President Barack Obama’s budget proposal called for a $20.3 million decrease in funding for the Institute of Museum and Library Services, the main source of federal aid for the nation’s museums and libraries. In January, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo proposed a 10 percent cut for library aid in the Education Department’s annual budget.

City residents fund branch libraries like Beauchamp, and county residents support the Central Library, said Elizabeth Dailey, executive director of the Onondaga County Public Library. Higher funding does not directly support local libraries, Dailey said, but federal and state grants fund special programs, such as the development of publicly accessible databases.

Onondaga County’s appropriations for branch libraries in the city of Syracuse have increased from $6,116,739 to $6,202,676 or 1.4 percent, between 2010 and 2011. But Dailey said the numbers are misleading.

“In dollars, the amount has gone up every year,” she said. “However you’ll hear almost everyone say libraries have been cut because the same amount of money supports fewer people and fewer materials.”

Reduced funding requires libraries to strip some services. In December, the Onondaga County Public Library announced its branches would not stay open past 7:30 p.m. Dailey said the change resulted from a decrease in staff and a decision to keep more employees at the libraries during the most popular visiting hours.

“It’s a challenge because we need to meet people’s needs,” Dailey said. “We have to meet people’s needs, so we have to use resources in the best way.”

Library users are so varied and their needs so different that it is difficult to determine what services to drop.

The inside of Beauchamp Branch Library.

The American Library Association says libraries are “the one place in America where the doors are open to everyone.” The libraries provide services to everyone, from college students studying for exams to grandparents emailing relatives living abroad. Computers and access to the Internet are vital for many library patrons. And that is becoming even more important during a recession.

Pamela Crane, the branch manager at Beauchamp, said computers give library users access to information.

“Public computer usage has increased,” she said. “We offer wireless access that’s being used more and more.”

Dailey explained the importance of having access to information about job opportunities online. “I don’t know if people realize this, but every major employer in Onondaga County requires a job application online.”

Computer use is on the rise, but the age-old practice of lending books and now DVDs is still a fundamental role of public libraries. So is providing a place to meet and a place for children to learn.

In the rear of Beauchamp, a flight of stairs leads to an auditorium that is often used for community meetings.

“The branches really are neighborhood centers,” Dailey said. “They are places where community members get together.”

Some of the greatest beneficiaries of public libraries are children. Richard Rogers, a sixth-grade teacher at the Edward Smith School in Syracuse, said public libraries are necessary for students, especially the less fortunate.

“Many of my students, up to 40 percent on a yearly basis, don’t have the means to buy books to read, let alone a computer and the Internet. Without a public library system, students would lack the resources necessary to complete some assignments expected to be completed,” Rogers said.

Dara Walker, a graduate student in Syracuse University’s African American Studies program, said events at the library, like last month’s “Black History Jeopardy,” inspire children to learn about their history and heritage.

“The key point is that they understand there is so much more about Black History and there is a way to learn about Black History that is A, culturally relevant, and B, can be fun,” Walker said.

Tatjyjana Verhage, a third-grader who played the quiz game, said she enjoyed “Daily Double” and learning about people like Martin Luther King Jr. and Rosa Parks.

Dailey said community members interested in supporting their libraries can contact local representatives.

“Some people don’t think their elected officials want to talk to them, but they do,” Dailey said. She said citizens should tell their local politicians, such as Assemblyman Samuel D. Roberts or County Legislator Monica Williams, what they need from their local public libraries.

“I would focus on what is needed, whatever your personal needs are, and ask for support.”